Is it fair to review four books at once? I think so, considering it is a series and I read all four in the course of three days.
Title: The Thief, The Queen of Attolia, The King of Attolia, A Conspiracy of Kings
Author: Megan Whalen Turner
Ratings: 4 stars, 3 stars, 4 stars, 3 stars
The first book was not supposed to be the best (according to whichever book blog I first heard about it from) but I loved it.
The Thief was a quick, fast-paced delight. I can imagine plenty of people enjoying it, but I plan on recommending it to my 11-year old nephew. A thief who brags he can steal anything but ends only gets caught for bragging about his successful thievery ("a professional risk" he calls it) and a hidden treasure all seem to be things that would keep his attention. There's a sprinkling of politics and human nature to give the book some depth, too, which I appreciated. The best part is, I was genuinely surprised by a few things, which doesn't happen much anymore since I've read so many books. I love a good surprise that is a shock because of how
I interpreted the narration as opposed to a red herring or details simply being excluded for the sake of surprise (also my pet peeve with Ocean's 12 since you can't actually follow along with the real theft because you don't even see the events until the end). It was obviously good enough that I ran right out to get the other 3 books that night.
Skipping ahead, my second favorite book was
The King of Attolia because it moved a little faster, had a little more danger, and made me laugh. I was well-prepared for the author's way of surprising me (after all, I'd read two of her books in two days at this point) but she still got me, even if it wasn't as shocking as in
The Thief. It was still a good enough surprise that I laughed out loud and had to reread the beginning.
The Queen of Attolia and
A Conspiracy of Kings were enjoyable, but much more drawn out. One of the things that made
The Thief so good was that it was so fast-paced. There were still plenty of good things about the second and fourth books, but I probably would not read them again. Possibly the big turn-off was the romance. I think every story is improved with someone being in love, but the romance in these two seemed forced. Boo.
The Thief, though, is
a keeper, as Kayla says. I make that decision based on what I'd want my kids to be delighted to find when they're desperate for a new book or one that I want to read over and over again.